On September 9, 2010, Hupy and Abraham's client was driving eastbound near the intersection of West Mason Street and South Ashland Avenue in Green Bay, Wisconsin. Unfortunately, she was rear-ended by a careless driver, causing neck and back pain that will require continuous treatment.

Initially, the insurance company tried to settle the claim with a $22,000 offer. Hupy and Abraham then filed suit, but the insurance company persisted with its low-ball approach, offering $28,000 at mediation. Before the trial even began, the insurance company caved and Attorney Shawn Brock obtained the $100,000 policy limit.